1st |
| Team | Time | | Description | Score | Max Pts |
|---|
| CIN | Top 1 | 0 | Billy Hamilton Out Chase Headley, Todd Frazier, pitcher Jordan Montgomery | 0-0 | 1 |
| CIN | Top 1 | 1 | Eugenio Suárez Out Tyler Wade, pitcher Jordan Montgomery | 0-0 | 1 |
| CIN | Top 1 | 2 | Joey Votto Out Aaron Judge, pitcher Jordan Montgomery | 0-0 | 1 |
| NYY | Bot 1 | 0 | Brett Gardner Out Joey Votto, Arismendy Alcántara, pitcher Luis Castillo | 0-0 | 1 |
| NYY | Bot 1 | 1 | Clint Frazier Strikeout, pitcher Luis Castillo | 0-0 | 2 |
| NYY | Bot 1 | 2 | Aaron Judge Out Devin Mesoraco, pitcher Luis Castillo | 0-0 | 1 |
|
2nd |
| CIN | Top 2 | 0 | Adam Duvall Walk, pitcher Jordan Montgomery | 0-0 | 1 |
| CIN | Top 2 | 0 | Patrick Kivlehan Strikeout, pitcher Jordan Montgomery | 0-0 | 2 |
| CIN | Top 2 | 1 | Devin Mesoraco Out Chase Headley, Didi Gregorius, pitcher Jordan Montgomery | 0-0 | 1 |
| NYY | Bot 2 | 0 | Matt Holliday Single, pitcher Luis Castillo | 0-0 | 1 |
| NYY | Bot 2 | 0 | Didi Gregorius Single, Matt Holliday to 2nd, pitcher Luis Castillo | 0-0 | 1 |
| NYY | Bot 2 | 0 | Chase Headley Single, Didi Gregorius to 2nd, Matt Holliday to 3rd, pitcher Luis Castillo | 0-0 | 1 |
| NYY | Bot 2 | 0 | Todd Frazier 1-Run Out Joey Votto, José Peraza, Matt Holliday scores, pitcher Luis Castillo | 0-1 | 2 |
|
3rd |
| CIN | Top 3 | 0 | Scott Schebler Out Didi Gregorius, pitcher Jordan Montgomery | 0-1 | 1 |
| CIN | Top 3 | 1 | José Peraza Out Aaron Judge, pitcher Jordan Montgomery | 0-1 | 1 |
| CIN | Top 3 | 2 | Arismendy Alcántara Out Aaron Judge, pitcher Jordan Montgomery | 0-1 | 1 |
| NYY | Bot 3 | 0 | Tyler Wade Out Joey Votto, Arismendy Alcántara, pitcher Luis Castillo | 0-1 | 1 |
| NYY | Bot 3 | 1 | Austin Romine Out Joey Votto, Luis Castillo, pitcher Luis Castillo | 0-1 | 1 |
| NYY | Bot 3 | 2 | Brett Gardner Walk, pitcher Luis Castillo | 0-1 | 1 |
| NYY | Bot 3 | 2 | Clint Frazier Out Joey Votto, Arismendy Alcántara, pitcher Luis Castillo | 0-1 | 1 |
|
4th |
| CIN | Top 4 | 0 | Billy Hamilton Out Aaron Judge, pitcher Jordan Montgomery | 0-1 | 1 |
| CIN | Top 4 | 1 | Eugenio Suárez Strikeout, pitcher Jordan Montgomery | 0-1 | 2 |
| CIN | Top 4 | 2 | Joey Votto Out Brett Gardner, pitcher Jordan Montgomery | 0-1 | 1 |
| NYY | Bot 4 | 0 | Aaron Judge Single, pitcher Luis Castillo | 0-1 | 1 |
| NYY | Bot 4 | 0 | Matt Holliday Out Joey Votto, José Peraza, Aaron Judge to 2nd, pitcher Luis Castillo | 0-1 | 1 |
| NYY | Bot 4 | 1 | Didi Gregorius 1-Run Sacrifice Fly, Aaron Judge scores, pitcher Luis Castillo | 0-2 | 2 |
| NYY | Bot 4 | 2 | Chase Headley Out Luis Castillo, Joey Votto, pitcher Luis Castillo | 0-2 | 1 |
|
5th |
| CIN | Top 5 | 0 | Adam Duvall Strikeout, pitcher Jordan Montgomery | 0-2 | 2 |
| CIN | Top 5 | 1 | Patrick Kivlehan Out Chase Headley, Didi Gregorius, pitcher Jordan Montgomery | 0-2 | 1 |
| CIN | Top 5 | 2 | Devin Mesoraco Out Chase Headley, Didi Gregorius, pitcher Jordan Montgomery | 0-2 | 1 |
| NYY | Bot 5 | 0 | Todd Frazier Single, pitcher Luis Castillo | 0-2 | 1 |
| NYY | Bot 5 | 0 | Tyler Wade Out, pitcher Luis Castillo | 0-2 | |
| NYY | Bot 5 | 1 | Austin Romine 1-Run Double, Tyler Wade scores, pitcher Luis Castillo | 0-3 | 3 |
| NYY | Bot 5 | 1 | Brett Gardner Single, Austin Romine to 3rd, pitcher Luis Castillo | 0-3 | 1 |
| NYY | Bot 5 | 1 | Clint Frazier Out, Brett Gardner to 2nd, pitcher Luis Castillo | 0-3 | |
| NYY | Bot 5 | 2 | Aaron Judge Walk, Clint Frazier to 2nd, Brett Gardner to 3rd, pitcher Luis Castillo | 0-3 | 1 |
| NYY | Bot 5 | 2 | Matt Holliday Out Joey Votto, Eugenio Suárez, pitcher Luis Castillo | 0-3 | 1 |
|
6th |
| CIN | Top 6 | 0 | Scott Schebler Double, pitcher Jordan Montgomery | 0-3 | 2 |
| CIN | Top 6 | 0 | José Peraza Out Brett Gardner, Scott Schebler to 3rd, pitcher Jordan Montgomery | 0-3 | 1 |
| CIN | Top 6 | 1 | Arismendy Alcántara 1-Run Out Chase Headley, Didi Gregorius, Scott Schebler scores, pitcher Jordan Montgomery | 1-3 | 2 |
| CIN | Top 6 | 2 | Billy Hamilton Strikeout, pitcher Jordan Montgomery | 1-3 | 2 |
| NYY | Bot 6 | 0 | Didi Gregorius Out Joey Votto, Arismendy Alcántara, pitcher Wandy Peralta | 1-3 | 1 |
| NYY | Bot 6 | 1 | Chase Headley Out Joey Votto, pitcher Wandy Peralta | 1-3 | 1 |
| NYY | Bot 6 | 2 | Todd Frazier Walk, pitcher Wandy Peralta | 1-3 | 1 |
| NYY | Bot 6 | 2 | Tyler Wade Out Joey Votto, Arismendy Alcántara, pitcher Wandy Peralta | 1-3 | 1 |
|
7th |
| CIN | Top 7 | 0 | Eugenio Suárez Strikeout, pitcher Jordan Montgomery | 1-3 | 2 |
| CIN | Top 7 | 1 | Joey Votto Strikeout, pitcher Jordan Montgomery | 1-3 | 2 |
| CIN | Top 7 | 2 | Adam Duvall Single, pitcher Jordan Montgomery | 1-3 | 1 |
| CIN | Top 7 | 2 | Scooter Gennett Out Brett Gardner, pitcher Tommy Kahnle | 1-3 | 1 |
| NYY | Bot 7 | 0 | Austin Romine Strikeout, pitcher Drew Storen | 1-3 | 2 |
| NYY | Bot 7 | 1 | Brett Gardner Strikeout, pitcher Drew Storen | 1-3 | 2 |
| NYY | Bot 7 | 2 | Clint Frazier Out Arismendy Alcántara, pitcher Drew Storen | 1-3 | 1 |
|
8th |
| CIN | Top 8 | 0 | Devin Mesoraco Walk, pitcher Dellin Betances | 1-3 | 1 |
| CIN | Top 8 | 0 | Scott Schebler Strikeout, pitcher Dellin Betances | 1-3 | 2 |
| CIN | Top 8 | 1 | José Peraza Walk, Devin Mesoraco to 2nd, pitcher Dellin Betances | 1-3 | 1 |
| CIN | Top 8 | 1 | Zack Cozart Out, Devin Mesoraco to 3rd, pitcher Dellin Betances | 1-3 | |
| CIN | Top 8 | 2 | Billy Hamilton 1-Run Double, Zack Cozart to 3rd, Devin Mesoraco scores, pitcher Dellin Betances | 2-3 | 3 |
| CIN | Top 8 | 2 | Eugenio Suárez Strikeout, pitcher Adam Warren | 2-3 | 2 |
| NYY | Bot 8 | 0 | Aaron Judge Strikeout, pitcher Michael Lorenzen | 2-3 | 2 |
| NYY | Bot 8 | 1 | Matt Holliday Out Joey Votto, pitcher Michael Lorenzen | 2-3 | 1 |
| NYY | Bot 8 | 2 | Didi Gregorius 1-Run Home Run, pitcher Michael Lorenzen | 2-4 | 7 |
| NYY | Bot 8 | 2 | Chase Headley Strikeout, pitcher Michael Lorenzen | 2-4 | 2 |
|
9th |
| CIN | Top 9 | 0 | Joey Votto Out Brett Gardner, pitcher Aroldis Chapman | 2-4 | 1 |
| CIN | Top 9 | 1 | Adam Duvall Out Chase Headley, Didi Gregorius, pitcher Aroldis Chapman | 2-4 | 1 |
| CIN | Top 9 | 2 | Scooter Gennett Out Clint Frazier, pitcher Aroldis Chapman | 2-4 | 1 |