In order to truly reflect the value of Punters, there needs to be points for yards downed inside the 20.
I think that what you've done with the Punter scoring is OK (currently we give 2 points for all punts downed inside the 20), but you have find a way to give more points for the deeper the ball is downed inside the 20. Whether it would be easier to give 1 point for a punt downed inside the 20 plus 0.1 for every yard getting closer to the endzone OR 3 points and -0.1 for every yard from the endzone, the end result would be the same. Punts downed inside the 20 would range from a bonus of 1.1 to 2.9 depending on what yardline (19-1) the ball is downed at.
I would settle for bonus points on punts downed inside 15, 10 or 5 yard line but I'm not sure that would be much easier to track. I won't stop asking for this feature. You added Punters. Now let's make better scoring (like you did with the sack yards).
Watching Johnny Hekker punt last night was impressive. With the scoring we have, he got 10 points for having all 5 punts downed inside the 20. He should have received 12.1 points for punts down at the 7 (2.3), 10 (2), 1 (2.9), 6 (2.4), and 5 (2.5).
OK, I really want to say that the scoring options for Kickers is awesome. In our league we give 3 points for FGs plus 0.1 points for every yard over 40 and 0.1 point for every yard over 50. So a 46 yard FG is 3.6, 50 yarder is 4, and a 60 yarder is 6. We contrast that with -3 points for missed FG but give 0.1 point for every yard over 20 up to 50 yards so that a missed 25 yard FG is -2.5, missed 40 yarder is -1, and any misses over 49 is 0. THAT IS TERRIFIC SCORING FOR KICKERS!!!
Why can't we do something similar with Punters? My P Michael Dickson this week had 4 punts all downed inside the 20. I got 8 points (2 for each), but I would have been happier if I got only 7.6 which results from 2.1 (downed at 9 yard), 2.8 (2), 1.6 (14), and 1.1 (19).
Following the week 6 bye Dickson has had only 1 punt downed inside the 20 for each of weeks 7 and 8. He got 2 for each but should have got 2.3 (7 yardline) and 1.5 (15 yardline), respectively.
This week Saints P Morstead had 5 punts downed inside the 20. He got 10 points for punts down at the 15, 12, 14, 11, and 10. With the scoring that I request, it would have been 1.5, 1.8, 1.6, 1.9, and 2 for a total of 8.8
Morstead didn't have any punts downed inside the 10. He had a good day, but it wasn't great.
Using Overall Punt Yards, Overall Avg Punt Yards (not Net), Punt Attempts (as a Negative Stat), and Touchbacks can help differentiate Punter Performance
Your comment is irrelevant. I want points depending on what yard the ball is downed on inside the 20. Punters who pin the opponent deep should get more fantasy points. That is not an option currently, but I won't quit demanding it until it is.
Congrats on recognizing that Punters are Fantasy Players too. This is the scoring I use for my leagues which gives a range of 20 to -2 points and an average of 7 points a week. The highest score ever by a Punter was Michael Dickson in his first NFL game, 21.2 (had 4 downed inside the 20 with a 57.5 net average):
2 points for every Punt Inside 20
-2 points for every Blocked Punt
-1 point for every Touchback Punt
1 point for every 100 Punt Net Yard (0.01 per)
1 point for every 2 Net Yards Per Punt points after reaching 38 total Net Yards Per Punt (0.5 per)
MonteMWed 7/29/20 11:22 AM
In order to truly reflect the value of Punters, there needs to be points for yards downed inside the 20.
I think that what you've done with the Punter scoring is OK (currently we give 2 points for all punts downed inside the 20), but you have find a way to give more points for the deeper the ball is downed inside the 20. Whether it would be easier to give 1 point for a punt downed inside the 20 plus 0.1 for every yard getting closer to the endzone OR 3 points and -0.1 for every yard from the endzone, the end result would be the same. Punts downed inside the 20 would range from a bonus of 1.1 to 2.9 depending on what yardline (19-1) the ball is downed at.
I would settle for bonus points on punts downed inside 15, 10 or 5 yard line but I'm not sure that would be much easier to track. I won't stop asking for this feature. You added Punters. Now let's make better scoring (like you did with the sack yards).
MonteMWed 2/9/22 4:45 PM
In my continued lobbying to have slightly improved scoring for Punters, Michael Dickson's 2021 Season by week:
1. 4=8pts as opposed to (12, 15, 14, 10) 1.8+1.5+1.6+2= 6.9pts
2. 2=4pts as opposed to (8, 18) 2.2+1.2= 3.4pts
3. 1=2pts as opposed to (11) 1.9pts
4. 2=4pts as opposed to (18, 9) 1.2+2.1= 3.3pts
5. 4=8pts as opposed to (12, 4, 18, 11) 1.8+2.6+1.2+1.9= 7.5pts
6. 1=2pts as opposed to (16) 1.4pts
7. 3=6pts as opposed to (12, 15, 15) 1.8+1.5+1.5= 4.8pts
8. 3=6pts as opposed to (19, 12, 9) 1.1+1.8+2.1= 5pts
9. bye
10. 4=8pts as opposed to (7, 9, 17, 13) 2.3+2.1+1.3+1.7= 7.4pts
11. 3=6pts as opposed to (18, 5, 15) 1.2+2.5+1.5= 5.2pts
12. 3=6pts as opposed to (9, 9, 13) 2.1+2.1+1.7= 5.9pts
13. 2=4pts as opposed to (8, 8) 2.2+2.2= 4.4pts
14. 2=4pts as opposed to (2, 18) 2.8+1.2= 4pts
15. 3=6pts as opposed to (12, 12, 13) 1.8+1.8+1.7= 5.3pts
The total points I got for punts inside the 20 was 78 points, but with better scoring it would have been only 66.4
Maybe I should adjust my hypothetical scoring to 0.2 per yard inside the 20. It sure would be nice to have that option.
noitankcapflowThu 2/10/22 12:39 PM
dickson has 3895 points in my league
MonteMThu 4/29/21 5:41 PM
When is Fleaflicker going to add this scoring stat for Punters?
MonteMTue 10/27/20 3:07 PM
Watching Johnny Hekker punt last night was impressive. With the scoring we have, he got 10 points for having all 5 punts downed inside the 20. He should have received 12.1 points for punts down at the 7 (2.3), 10 (2), 1 (2.9), 6 (2.4), and 5 (2.5).
MonteMTue 9/22/20 6:40 PM
OK, I really want to say that the scoring options for Kickers is awesome. In our league we give 3 points for FGs plus 0.1 points for every yard over 40 and 0.1 point for every yard over 50. So a 46 yard FG is 3.6, 50 yarder is 4, and a 60 yarder is 6. We contrast that with -3 points for missed FG but give 0.1 point for every yard over 20 up to 50 yards so that a missed 25 yard FG is -2.5, missed 40 yarder is -1, and any misses over 49 is 0. THAT IS TERRIFIC SCORING FOR KICKERS!!!
Why can't we do something similar with Punters? My P Michael Dickson this week had 4 punts all downed inside the 20. I got 8 points (2 for each), but I would have been happier if I got only 7.6 which results from 2.1 (downed at 9 yard), 2.8 (2), 1.6 (14), and 1.1 (19).
MonteMThu 10/15/20 12:57 PM
Dickson has continued his solid season of punting:
Week 3: 6 points for 3 punts downed at 13 (1.7), 19 (1.1), 1 (2.9) instead of 5.7 points
Week 4: 2 points for 1 punt downed at 16 (1.4) instead of 1.4 points
Week 5: 8 points for 4 punts downed at 2 (2.8), 12 (1.8), 15 (1.5) 3 (2.7) instead of 8.8 points
I won't stop with my calculations until this scoring option becomes available.
MonteMMon 11/2/20 12:07 PM
Following the week 6 bye Dickson has had only 1 punt downed inside the 20 for each of weeks 7 and 8. He got 2 for each but should have got 2.3 (7 yardline) and 1.5 (15 yardline), respectively.
MonteMFri 12/11/20 4:37 PM
Week 9 Dickson had no punts downed inside the 20.
Week 10: 4 points, punts downed at 7 (2.3), 12 (1.8) instead of 4.1 points
Week 11: 2 points, punt downed at 14, instead of 1.6 points
Week 12: 2 points, punt downed at 16, instead of 1.4 points
Week 13: 4 points, punts downed at 9 (2.1), 5 (2.5) instead of 4.6 points
MonteMMon 1/4/21 4:27 PM
GREAT NEWS, I was able to win both my leagues with Dickson as my Punter. Here is the final recap for his punts inside the 20:
Week 14: 2 points, punt downed at 9, instead of 2.1 points
Week 15: 8 points, punts downed at 4 (2.6), 10 (2) 4 (2.6), 14 (1.6) instead of 8.8 points
Week 16: 8 points, punts downed at 13 (1.7), 12 (1.8) 14 (1.6), 12 (1.8) instead of 6.9 points
Season: 64 points (32 punts) instead of 65.1 points
PLEASE GRANT MY REQUEST TO HAVE THE OPTION TO AWARD POINTS BASED ON WHAT YARD THE PUNT IS DOWNED AT INSIDE THE 20. THANKS!
MonteMFri 9/4/20 7:14 PM
ALL PUNTS INSIDE THE 20 ARE NOT EQUAL!!!
MonteMTue 9/15/20 6:23 PM
This week Saints P Morstead had 5 punts downed inside the 20. He got 10 points for punts down at the 15, 12, 14, 11, and 10. With the scoring that I request, it would have been 1.5, 1.8, 1.6, 1.9, and 2 for a total of 8.8
Morstead didn't have any punts downed inside the 10. He had a good day, but it wasn't great.
Yami-RonSun 9/20/20 5:20 AM
Using Overall Punt Yards, Overall Avg Punt Yards (not Net), Punt Attempts (as a Negative Stat), and Touchbacks can help differentiate Punter Performance
MonteMSun 9/20/20 12:14 PM
Your comment is irrelevant. I want points depending on what yard the ball is downed on inside the 20. Punters who pin the opponent deep should get more fantasy points. That is not an option currently, but I won't quit demanding it until it is.
noitankcapflowThu 2/18/21 8:38 PM
ive just added punters to my leagur custom scoing
MonteMFri 2/19/21 9:59 AM
Congrats on recognizing that Punters are Fantasy Players too. This is the scoring I use for my leagues which gives a range of 20 to -2 points and an average of 7 points a week. The highest score ever by a Punter was Michael Dickson in his first NFL game, 21.2 (had 4 downed inside the 20 with a 57.5 net average):
2 points for every Punt Inside 20
-2 points for every Blocked Punt
-1 point for every Touchback Punt
1 point for every 100 Punt Net Yard (0.01 per)
1 point for every 2 Net Yards Per Punt points after reaching 38 total Net Yards Per Punt (0.5 per)
noitankcapflowFri 2/19/21 10:18 AM
mine are no there no decimials in my league here Punting
1 point for every Punt Yard P
5 points for every Punt Inside 20 after reaching 5 total Punts Inside 20 P
MonteMFri 2/19/21 12:06 PM
That's awful scoring. I don't feel sorry for anyone stupid enough to join your public leagues. Good luck though.
noitankcapflowFri 2/19/21 12:20 PM
cut throat league